The lesson of loss
The weekend after
Christmas, we were visiting
my brother and sisterin-
law in their suburban
Boston home. Posey and
Bee had made the trip with
us, but our grown-up son
Xerxes stayed home so he
could hang out with friends
who were home from college,
as well as watch after
the house and the pets.
Saturday night, we had
just finished supper when
he called. Our Sheltie Sassy
had gotten out, and he
couldn’t find her. Now, it
has happened before that
the drafty front door of our
mid-1800s house has blown
open, and our dogs have
taken themselves on a little
walk. But they’re confirmed
homebodies, so I fully expected
her to show up on
the doorstep any minute.
An hour later, he called
again. A neighbor found
Sassy. She had been hit by
a car. She was gone.
Pets add so much to the
life of a family. When I was
growing up, we always had
pets. My very earliest memories
are of crawling across
the kitchen floor with our
marmalade tabby cat, inspecting
the world from our
shared vantage point.
We always had at least
one dog and a couple cats to
care for. As a parent, I’ve
always thought it was important
for my children to
have pets.
Pets teach responsibility
in a way that nothing else
can, with the possible exception
of children. They
need you. They depend on
you. They don’t eat if you
don’t feed them. (Unless
they can find their way into
a tasty trash bag, that is.)
And to be honest, pets
can be a pain. They wake
you up early with requests
for food or walks or trips
outdoors. They bark at
menacing things such as
chipmunks, passing cyclists
and falling leaves and snow.
They scratch the furniture,
pee on the carpet and try to
smell your boss’ backside
when you throw that promotion-
seeking dinner party.
If there is any lesson
worth teaching your children
- or learning yourself
- it’s the rich value of caring
for something that does not
have the capacity to either
appreciate or reciprocate
that care. It’s called altruism,
unconditional love (or
if you’re not a pet person)
the psychosis of animal lovers.
At the same time that
pets teach altruism, they
also teach trust. So many of
the messages we give our
children go against the notion
of trust as a virtue. We
teach them to be wary of
strangers. We teach them
to protect themselves from
bullies. We teach them to
compete with their peers.
In our house, we teach them
an active mistrust of advertising
and media sales
pitches.
But trust is also a virtue.
Trust is essential for
healthy relationships be-tween friends, spouses and
families. Parents can teach
trust by being trustworthy,
but throwing a dog into the
mix can reinforce the idea
that trusting someone is
okay.
Don’t try to teach your children
trust with a pet cat.
Cats don’t trust their people
- they tolerate them.
But the most important
thing a pet can teach a child
is also the most difficult
lesson to watch a child
learn. Loss. Grief. Mortality.
Posey and Bee have an
intellectual knowledge of
loss of a loved one. They’ve
begun to try to connect family
members, so they understand
that their dad’s father
- their grandfather
- died before they had a
chance to know him. And
they know from photographs
what my mother
looked like, and also that
she died.
Bee understands death
first and foremost as a
union with God. ``Grandma
Mary is with God,’’ she will
tell me. I agree with her because
I think that’s not a
bad way to understand
death.
Posey is 3, so death
seems - like everything else
- something temporary and
malleable. Like the rule
against standing on top of
the table.
When we got home from
Boston, we gathered the
girls in the den, along with
Xerxes, and told them that
we had some sad news.
``Sassy got out and she was
hit by a car and she died,’’
we told them.
They repeated those
words, but it was unclear
just how well they understood
the meaning.
We buried Sassy in the
backyard, just next to a
young lilac tree. Afterward,
we stood around her grave
and recounted the things
about her that made us
happy and made us laugh.
We expressed our gratitude
for the time we were
able to spend with her. We
laughed about the way she
loved apples, and would
even root through a grocery
bag and steal one if she got
the chance.
We remembered the way
she tried in all her nervous,
instinctively herding, utterly
maternal way to take
care of all of us.
We remembered the way
she would try to lick your
feet if she thought you were
sad. Creepy, yes, but unbelievably
sweet and kind.
Since then, Posey and
Bee have been processing
the loss in different ways.
Posey has been learning
the basics of loss, and will
tell me a couple times a day
that Sassy died from a car
and that we miss her. Posey
has expressed a 5-year-old’s
grief, talking about how she
wishes it had not happened.
They have not broken
down in tears, being maybe
too young or not quite attached
enough to what was,
undeniably, a rather neurotic
dog.
But they are experiencing
this loss, this grief, this
feeling that there is someone
missing from our home
- someone who cannot be
replaced.
Elizabeth Trever Buchinger
misses her dog. You
can connect with her by emailing
VillageWordsmith@gmail.
com or visiting my website.
This Wonderful Life
January 8, 2009
This Wonderful Life
- This Wonderful Life
-
- This Wonderful Life: I can say No, but I prefer Yes If popular culture is any indication, it seems women suffer from an epidemic inability to refuse additional responsibilities. Magazines, self-help books and therapists nationwide offer heaps of advice on how to assert oneself, draw boundaries and generally say No when asked to sign on for those things for which we have little time and less interest.
- This Wonderful Life: I wish someone had told me Disclaimer: Because my son more or less demanded that I stop using him and his life as material for my column back when he was 12 or 13, I want to make it perfectly clear to all my readers (and any legal professionals who are now retained or may be retained at some future time by aforementioned son) that this column is not about him. It’s about me. The fact that he happened to turn 21 on Saturday is mere coincidence. So help me God.
- This Wonderful Life: A view through bare branches Every morning, Bee and I stand at the end of the driveway waiting for her bus and we look up into the branches of the elm tree that arches over the drive.
- This Wonderful Life: To Posey on her fourth So here we are, on the other side of 3-years-old, and it seems we both survived it intact. It wasn’t easy, but perhaps it made us both stronger.
- This Wonderful Life: A Posey by any other name... A few weeks ago, Posey gave us all new names. Or, to be more accurate, Posey gave us all one new name. Rose.
- This Wonderful Life: Are pork chops really that good? If it seems unlikely for a vegetarian (that would be me) to own a couple of table- bound pigs, it probably seems downright absurd that their names should be Tender and Delicious.
- This Wonderful Life: I sssssseeeeeee you there The first thing you should know is that I used to suffer from a snake phobia. The operative word there is phobia. It wasn’t just a matter of disliking snakes. It wasn’t a fear of being bitten. It wasn’t a simple reluctance to touch their impossibly dry, nimble bodies.
- This Wonderful Life: What’s so funny? My kids, I hope In my experience as a three-time parent, there is something absolutely, spiritually magical about the first time your child cracks a joke.
- This Wonderful Life: Who are these little girls? There are two children in my house who bear a striking resemblance to my daughters. They are adorable, smart and energetic.
- This Wonderful Life: A harvest that’s good for the soul Signs of harvest are all around. The afternoon sun glows amber over the fields and the farm stands are filled to overflowing with vegetables and fruit. We’re lucky to live in a place where we can have such an immediate connection to the food we eat.
- More This Wonderful Life Headlines

