COOPERSTOWN —
I was an American history major in college and one topic that my professors never discussed was prohibition.
This ``oversight’’ occurred in spite of the fact I took several intensive classes on 20th century America, and my senior thesis class focused on issues from 1890-1940. After reading Daniel Okrent’s new book, ``Last Call: The Rise and Fall of Prohibition,’’ it’s hard to understand how the subject could have been so consistently ignored.
One commentator has referred to the book as the authoritative work on prohibition. It’s probably true. I doubt another title has looked as in-depth into the topic as this one. But why is a mystery to me. After reading Okrent’s work I not only found an overlooked piece of American history but one that provides valuable object lessons into the way our nation’s politicians make decisions today.
For those of you not familiar with it (and considering how it’s glossed over in history classes, that’s very likely) prohibition was passed as the 18th Amendment to the Constitution in 1919. Its passage basically banned the drinking of alcoholic beverages except for medicinal and religious purposes.
If you find it hard to believe in this day and ageof over-hyped wine and beer commercials that prohibition could have actually existed you also won’t be surprised to find out it was a colossal failure. In 1933 it was repealed by the 21st Amendment. The story of how prohibition managed to pass in the first place, how difficult it was to enforce once it was enacted, and how it managed to be repealed after 14 years is a fascinating one.
One thing that stands out in the 50 years that prohibitionists fought to have an amendment was their unusual coalition of supporters.
Progressives who saw it as a sin and vice were joined by suffragettes, racists, and nativists. Women pushing for the right to vote were tired of having to deal with husbands who would come home drunk after work.
Southern whites stereotyped former slaves as drunks who raped white women (the Ku Klux Klan were avid supporters of prohibition). And nativists who hated Irish and German immigrants saw those people as drunks who debased society.
The common theme is ``drunk.’’ There is no question that there was a huge increase in the number of saloons and drinking establishments around the country as the 19th century wore on. Still, the movement to ban alcohol seemed overwhelming because it takes two-thirds of Congress and three-quarters of the states to pass a constitutional amendment. But as we see today clever political maneuverings can overcome what seems like long odds.
One thing that helped the ``dry’’ movement was that there were four constitutional amendments passed during the second decade of the 20th Century. The direct election of senators, the federal income tax, and women’s suffrage all led up to the passage of prohibition. For example, suffragettes and ``dry’’ advocates represented a common coalition. Employers also supported it as a way to keep their workers from coming to work intoxicated.
Of course, what works in theory doesn’t necessarily work in practice. When enough people want something they often find ways to get it whether it’s illegal or not. Just look at prostitution and drug use today. The passage of prohibition opened up a black market that enterprising entrepreneurs learned how to exploit. It also led to the rise of organized crime. Not only was there a huge market for illegal booze but there was no tax on it either.
Recent studies indicate that prohibition cut alcohol consumption by 30 percent in the U.S.
That doesn’t sound bad until you realize that the whole idea was to reduce it by 100%. A .300 batting average is pretty good in baseball but not with a constitutional amendment.
Enforcement of prohibition became something of a joke in many cases. When Al Smith became governor of New York he pushed through a law that banned state funding to enforce it. Saloons and ``speakeasies’’ in New York City operated openly in many cases.
The ``wets’’ started to shift the momentum towards repeal in the mid-20s. They were led by several corporate chieftains who despised the dry movement.
As conservatives they hated the federal income tax and corporate tax and thought re-establishing legalized alcohol and taxing it would undo the need for the other duties.
The Great Depression also helped the cause as the federal government needed the tax revenue that repealing prohibition would bring.
There are many lessons to be learned from the experience of the 18th Amendment and its eventual repeal. For one thing, politics and the manipulation of the federal system have gone on throughout our history and aren’t new phenomena.
There were just as many politicians back then who talked out of both sides of their mouth and weren’t as ``moral’’ as they claimed to be (Sound familiar?).
Also, taking away individual rights often brings about a backlash that makes enforcement difficult and opens up a black market.
And the experience may present a template on how to deal with such current issues as the war on drugs.
Prohibition was passed mainly because it was considered immoral and dragging down society. Its failure provides a life lesson in how not to deal with a societal ill. It’s a shame that our U.S. history curriculum tends to gloss over it. It’s an important and fascinating part of our history. Okrent’s work isn’t perfect.
It reads like a textbook at times, and at one point he digresses into an impassioned but unnecessary defense of Joe Kennedy who was commonly suspected of being a bootlegger. But those are minor flaws. There is so much valuable information here. It should be considered a must read.
DAVID KENT is the Cooperstown Village Librarian.
Columns
Book Notes: Prohibition should not be ignored
- Columns
-
-
In These Otsego Hills: The losses are adding up ...
It is with sadness that we note the passing of long time friend, and distantrelative, Jane Patrick. Over the years we have worked with Jane in a number of organizations including Women’s Club and the Community Advisory Committee at Bassett. And, of course, in later years we joined her, along with the other Dinner Belles, for any number of delicious meals. But we do think that our favorite memory that we shared with Jane was when we discovered, having both married Cooperstown natives, that we shared Cooperstown Christmas plans.
Continued ... -
Up On Hawthorn Hill: Bird Feeder?
Bird feeder is a relative term. At least that is the case around here. A few mornings ago we spotted the first rabbit to visit the feeders. Normally, all we see during the winter are rabbit tracks crisscrossing the gardens.
Continued ... -
From Fly Creek: Cheers for the Blue Rabbit!
My handwriting’s always been an embarrassment. Way back in elementary school, while most of the others were developing a clear, sometimes graceful hand (especially the girls), my penmanship showed no improvement.
Continued ... -
In These Otsego Hills: This and that ...
We have found the weather so far this year to be on the unusual side. And while we have no problem with the fact that we have received very little snow, we are of the opinion that what we have had instead is not particularly to our liking either. In fact, we are very hesitant to venture out much as we live in fear that the rain will turn to mixed precipitation which will freeze into a sheet of ice. And we are definitely opposed to encountering a sheet of ice underfoot. In fact, we are so hesitant that we now have taken to canceling our participation in events based on what just might be a dubious forecast.
Continued ... -
Book Notes: Feinstein’s latest is sheer enjoyment
Most people who follow sports have probably heard of John Feinstein. As a nationally known author, sportswriter, pundit and broadcaster, he has brought a unique angle to sports journalism. His groundbreaking book on Bobby Knight’s 1986-87 Indiana University basketball team, “A Season on the Brink,” still resonates today as an all-time classic.
Continued ... -
Book Notes: No Trekkie should miss Shatner’s books
It would be hard to find a television phenomenon as popular as “Star Trek.” Even though it was only on television for three seasons and 79 episodes (1966-69) it attracted viewers and devotees that still follow it passionately 45 years later. The fanatical supportspawned several movies and television spinoffs. Star Trek conventions continue to this day. There has never been anything like it.
Continued ... -
Up on Hawthorn Hill: Making sense of things
A book I have been reading investigates the various ways over time that we have made sense of the world. It carries the reader through to the present via several seminal classical texts and ultimately aims to suggest a strategy for “ finding meaning in a secular age.”
Continued ... -
In These Otsego Hills: ‘Property must be secured or liberty cannot exist.’ − John Adams
Last week we were asked if we would be interested in previewing a documentary, “The Empire State Divide,”produced by the Foundation for Land & Liberty. And we were more than happy to do so as we understood the documentary dealt with the problems that continue to face family farms.
Continued ... -
From Fly Creek: Now wait a minute!
On the ninth day of Christmas, driving down Cooperstown’s Eagle Street, I saw something astounding! No, not “nineladies dancing, eight maids a-milking, seven swans” etc. I saw one jogger jogging. And puffing on a cigarette.
Continued ... -
In These Otsego Hills: Goals of the past and goals of the future
We have long subscribed to the concept that we are always more successful if we, number one, set a goal and then, number two, meet it. And this was our thinking when we decided before Christmas to watch at least part of every college football bowl game. It was perhaps an odd, if not completely nonsensical, goal.
Continued ... -
In These Otsego Hills: Not to our liking ...
It is with sadness that we note the recent death of Steve Nagel. The son-inlaw of our late husband’s cousins, Alice and Harvey Eckler of Fly Creek, Steve was married to the Ecklers’ oldest daughter, Gail. We had the pleasure of spending Christmas Eve with the Nagels and the Ecklers in Fly Creek, greatly enjoying the delicious food and delightful conversation.
Continued ... -
Up on Hawthorn Hill: Of birds and faith
I watch birds quite a bit. Every five days or so I send in a report to Cornell as partof its annual Project Feeder Watch program. The data, collected from volunteers from all over the country, enables scientists to track population trends. I would spend quite a bit of time checking out the visitors to our feeders anyway. Participating in the feeder program makes a personal pleasure that much more meaningful. It is rare that aesthetical and scientific endeavors work in tandem.
Continued ... -
Book Notes: Biography captures the real Stephen Colbert
It would be hard to find a comedian as unique as Stephen Colbert. As the host of “The Colbert Report” on Comedy Central he hasmanaged to leave his mark on the nation’s consciousness in both a serious and humorous sort of way. His unusual wit has allowed him to become American icon. It would be difficult to find another entertainer quite like him.
Continued ... -
From Fly Creek: Christmas and varied blessings
I’m still astounded! The last farmers’ market before Christmas, I was sitting up front, directly under the ceiling heater, shmoozing with the hoi-polloi. (That’s an awkward linguistic mix,but let’s let it go.) As I sipped my hot coffee, a gloved hand came to rest on my shoulder and a warm voice said, “Merry Christmas, Jim.” I looked to my left—it was Santa Claus!
Continued ... -
In These Otsego Hills: Always a learning experience ...
We must admit that we thoroughly enjoyed our 2011 Christmas celebration. We partook of Christmas Eve dinner at the home of Alice and Harvey Eckler of Fly Creek and Christmas Day dinner at the home of Sandy and Al Bullard of Milford. We had our usual Christmas Day brunch at home on Pioneer Street, although we must admit it was a tad bit later than usual as, what we enjoyed most about Christmas, namely our granddaughter Abby, took a great deal of time opening her Christmas presents.
Continued ... -
In These Otsego Hills: Coming up ... 2012
Difficult as it seems, 2011 is fast coming to an end. And it is always our hope that as a year draws to a close, the issues which have been in the forefront during the year will be resolved. Unfortunately, we suspect that will not be the case this year. Instead, we are fairly certain that many of the issues that plagued this year, will continue to plague next year. Thus we will find ourselves still musing about the same issues we have spent time with already. And while we have not come toany conclusions about many of the issues, we do think they would all likely benefit from both sides thinking critically about perspective, risk assessment and possible solutions.
Continued ... -
Up on Hawthorn Hill: Circularity
When she was a puppy my dog Gabby would run in what I described then as “circles of joy.” She celebrated her15th birthday a few weeks ago and despite the inevitable frailties that old age imposes upon all of us, she is doing pretty well.
Continued ... -
Book Notes: Grisham doesn’t disappoint
John Grisham is one of this country’s most popular authors. Every time he publishes a book it’s an instant best-seller. He appeared on the scene about 20 years ago with his tense legal thrillers, “A Time to Kill” and “The Firm,”and hasn’t stopped producing top-notch novels since.
Continued ... -
From Fly Creek: Still singing, beyond our hearing
This column from Christmas 2001 still speaks deeply to me, and perhaps will to you, too. Take it, please, as my Christmas gift.
Continued ... -
In These Otsego Hills: The 2011 Cooperstown Carol
Since 1984, with the exception of one year, 1999, we have looked forward at the end of the year to going through all the issues of the paper in order to glean those news items which have been worthy of note throughout the year and which should make their way into our annual Cooperstown Carol.
Continued ...
-
In These Otsego Hills: The losses are adding up ...
